logo
logo
  • Home
  • Babies
  • Family Life
  • Kids
  • Pregnancy
  • Teenagers
  • My Family Life
  • Babies

The Best Nipple Shields for Breastfeeding Mothers

My Family Life Reviews Team
Written By My Family Life Reviews Team
Last updated: Mar 31, 2025, 02:21 PM
Affiliate Disclosure ↓
Nipple Shields

Nipple shields are an affordable and convenient hack for mothers going through the joys and struggles of breastfeeding.

Breastfeeding can be a beautiful but challenging journey for new moms, often accompanied by unexpected pain. Nipple shields like the Koala Babycare Nursing Cups play a crucial role in this journey, offering not only comfort but also protection for cracked nipples. These shields mimic the natural shape of a nipple, making breastfeeding easier and more comfortable.

Motherhood can be a whirlwind experience, and small things like nipple shields can leave a huge impact on improving your daily life. As they say, a little goes a long way. In this guide, we’ll help you find the perfect nipple shield for your needs, ensuring a smoother breastfeeding experience. Keep reading to discover our top picks for nipple shields in 2025 and explore the options below!

View all Contents
  • Finding Your Next Nipple Shields: A Buyer’s Guide
    • How To Pick the Correct Size of Nipple Shields
    • How To Use Nipple Shields
    • What To Look For in Nipple Shields
  • People Also Asked
  • Why Trust Us?
  • Contributors

Our Top Picks

  • Koala Babycare Silver Nipple Shield: Best Overall (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this ↓
  • Lansinoh Nipple Shield: Most Portable (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this ↓
  • Bamibi Silver Nipple Shield: Most Eco-Friendly (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this ↓
  • Medela Contact Nipple Shield: Best for Beginners (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this ↓
  • Momcozy Contact Nipple Shields: Unique Features (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this ↓

Comparing the Best Nipple Shields of 2025

Koala Babycare Silver Nipple Shield

Best Overall
image
Check On Amazon

Available in two sizes, the Koala Babycare Silver Nipple Shields are a game changer if you’re new to the world of breastfeeding and struggling to find your rhythm. The silver’s natural healing and soothing properties help soothe and heal your extremely cracked and painful nipples. They also act as a barrier between the delicate nipple area and clothing that can further irritate them.

They are environmentally friendly and can be reused for as long as you need and even in the future. Completely odorless, they fit great on all breast shapes and sizes perfectly and can hardly be seen under clothes. You can easily forget they’re there because of how comfortable they feel around the sensitive nipple area, making them one of the best options on our list.

Product Pros
  • Doesn’t alter the taste of breastmilk
  • Soothes and heals nipples
  • Discreet under clothing
  • Multiple sizes available
Product Cons
  • Material can feel uncomfortable against skin

Lansinoh Nipple Shield

Most Portable
image
Check On Amazon

The Lansinoh Nipple shields provide a simple solution to common latching issues that many new mothers experience. This product is made out of skin-like silicone that will mimic the feeling of real skin and make your child more comfortable. This material is completely safe for both mothers and babies, as the silicone is completely BPA and BPS-free.

If you’re a mom who frequently has to breastfeed while on the go, you will be happy to know that this pick comes with a simple carrying case that is very discreet. Check these out if you need nipple shields that are great quality without breaking the bank.

Product Pros
  • Encourages close contact
  • Ultra-lightweight material
  • Available in multiple sizes
Product Cons
  • Comes with only one pair

Bamibi Silver Nipple Shield

Most Eco-Friendly
image
Check On Amazon

The Bamibi Silver Nipple Shields fit comfortably and discreetly under your nursing bra. The silver has healing properties that will work quickly on your body and leave your nipples feeling less strained. The fit of this product also aids in the healing process; the snug fit of the shields helps prevent chafing and irritation.

This pick is also super easy to clean and comes with a tasteful pouch to carry them around in. Not only are these shields easy to clean, but they are also a great choice for any new moms that value eco-friendly products. This pick can be reused many times and creates much less waste than other options. Not only is this a great pick for new moms but it also makes a perfect gift for baby showers. 

Product Pros
  • Chemical-free and hygienic
  • Provides natural nipple relief
  • Fits comfortably and discreetly 
  • Environmentally friendly and reusable
Product Cons
  • Does not fit all breasts

Medela Contact Nipple Shield

Best for Beginners
image
Check On Amazon

These nipple shields from Medela are the perfect choice for new moms who worry about finding a product that will fit them. This pick comes with three size options and even has a helpful size guide to help you with your purchase. The material of these shields is specifically made to help with flat or inverted nipples. The silky silicone material is 100% BPA-free and is designed to enhance skin-to-skin contact.

This product is great for new moms because it comes with a convenient guide that will walk you through the process of using the shields. This is especially helpful for first-time moms and those who have never used shields before.

Product Pros
  • Material mimics skin
  • Stylish carrying case
  • Large size variety
Product Cons
  • Shields stick on poorly

Momcozy Contact Nipple Shields

Unique Features
image
Check On Amazon

Some moms might be concerned with using nipple shields, worried that it might affect their bonding time with their baby. If you fall into this category, don’t fret. Momcozy Contact Nipple Shields are here to soothe your worries. This product’s unique designs are made to ensure maximum skin contact with your baby despite the barrier. This is possible through the product’s unique cut-out design that connects mom and baby during breastfeeding. Easy to clean and made of safe materials, these nipple shields are perfect for moms who are eager to maintain as much skin-to-skin contact with their baby. 

Product Pros
  • Maximum skin-to-skin contact
  • Made of 100% food-grade silicon, and BPA and BPS-free
  • Comes with a convenient storage case
Product Cons
  • Can take some time for baby to latch

Finding Your Next Nipple Shields: A Buyer’s Guide

Are you ready to start healing your sore nipples and stop accidental leaking? Now that you have perused all of our favorite picks, you are probably ready to jump and make a purchase right now. But, don’t make any hasty decisions before reading our well-researched buying guide. Below, we will walk you through all of the small details that you should check before buying your next pair of nipple shields.

How To Pick the Correct Size of Nipple Shields

When venturing out into the world of nipple shields, you must know what size will work the best for the shape of your nipples. First, you should reach out to your doctor for an opinion on what shields will work the best for you and then begin to determine what your size is.  Having a perfectly sized shield will help reduce pain, friction and ensure that you have the best flow of milk. Choosing the right size can be a tricky experience since you need one that not only suits your nipple but also your baby. To help find the right one that works for long-term use, you will have to consider a variety of sizes as the years go on. So while it is best for newborns to have a small nipple shield, you might have to replace it with a medium or even large as they get older. 

How To Use Nipple Shields

The idea of using a nipple shield can seem odd to people that are unfamiliar with them. But, do not worry because using a nipple shield is not nearly as difficult as it may seem. First, you should know that nipple shields will not adhere to dry skin. A key tip is to squeeze out a few drops of breastmilk onto the shield since they attach the best to damp skin. If you are using shields that are made out of a soft material, you are going to use the adhesive on the material to attach it to your skin. Once you have it carefully positioned, remove the adhesive and stick it on to make sure all the moisture is caught on the pad for maximum protection. Shields made out of soft materials are the best choice for people that want minimal outlines from the shields and require maximum comfort. 

What To Look For in Nipple Shields

A new mom’s journey is nothing if not confusing and full of doubts. One of the most frustrating parts of becoming a mom is breastfeeding, as it does not come naturally to everyone. Luckily, nipple shields can be extremely helpful in this case. Nipple shields can help your child latch onto you and prevent any injuries. Before you choose a set of nipple shields to wear, you should keep in mind a few factors. Here are some of the most important features to consider before making a purchase. 

Shape

The shape of your nipple shield should resemble, if not mimic, the shape of your nipple and areola so your baby can easily latch onto it. Since the main goal of a nipple shield is to assist you in getting your breastfeeding game on, it is important to get the right shape so your baby feels comfortable latching on.

Size

You should use the size of your breasts and nipples as a useful guideline for deciding on which size will work the best for you. Many companies will offer a size guide to help you decide which size will fit you.

Material

The material you buy should be safe for both your baby and you. A useful tip would be to always use BPA-free products for your baby. The most common materials used for nipple shields are silicone and silver. 

Brand

When it comes to something as sensitive as the nipple area and involves your little one, you can never be too careful so don’t even think about compromising on the quality for a few hundred bucks. Anything that is not top-notch isn’t worth investing in and putting you and your baby’s life in danger.

People Also Asked

Do I need nipple shields?

The decision on whether or not you use nipple shields is an extremely personal one that you should consult with your doctor about. Ideally, nipple shields help you relieve the pain from chapped and extremely sore nipples while helping your baby latch on well.

How will nipple shields help me?

Nipple shields work best for moms facing several difficulties such as inverted nipples. The most common problem that nipple shields solve is the problem of sore nipples from breastfeeding. Nipple shields will help your nipple heal quicker by providing a hygienic and snug covering (much like a bandaid).

How can I clean my nipple shields?

The best way to clean nipple shields is to wash them with warm and soapy water. But, it is always best to follow the directions given with the product. Some shields are super convenient and can be cleaned in a washing machine.

What is the purpose of a nipple shield?

A nipple shield is essentially designed to act as a second nipple. It lays on top of your niple and transfers milk from your breast to the baby's mouth. In some ways, you can call it a medium for the breastfeeding process, with the added benefit of protecting your nipples from aggravation and helping infants latch onto the breast faster and stronger.

Can nipple shields work on flat nipples?

Yes, nipple shields can work on flat nipples, but you will have to search for the correct product that suits your needs. Nipple shields come in all shapes and sizes to suit all types of nipples.

Why Trust Us?

You can trust My Family Life to provide practical tips and product recommendations that genuinely prioritize your family's best interests. As parents ourselves, our mission is to create a supportive community where you feel empowered and informed, knowing that we genuinely care about making your parenting experience as smooth and joyful as possible.

Contributors

My Family Life Reviews Team
My Family Life Reviews Team
Back to top
logo

©2025. All Rights Reserved

  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Terms
Contact

[email protected]

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Click here to learn more about our process.